Bottled water denounced & a list of brands that experts recommend to avoid

Even if you use a filter that you change the activated carbon cartridge each month to soften it, the tap water is only 2 to 3 cents per liter, while some bottled water comes back to more than one euro a liter.

2. Potentially hazardous chemicals in bottled water

In fact, it takes a lot of oil to make plastic bottles. For example, the amount of oil needed to make plastic water bottles in the United States could supply about a million cars and light trucks for a year. (The source)

Not long ago, German researchers discovered endocrine disruptors (EDs) that could harm the development and reproduction of 18 brands of bottled water. Of the 24,520 suspect chemicals present in bottled water, one that showed consistent results and illustrated anti-androgenic and anti-estrogenic activity was di (2-ethylhexyl) fumarate (DEHF). Endocrine disruptors are chemicals that can disrupt the hormonal system; they can cause cancerous tumors, congenital malformations, cardiovascular disorders, metabolic disorders, and, as mentioned earlier, other developmental disorders.

“A growing number of in vitro studies report the presence of endocrine disruptors in bottled water [12], [13], [14], [15], [17] . With previous studies focusing on estrogenicity, this work provides evidence of additional contamination with steroid receptor antagonists. Using an optimized extraction procedure, we detected anti – oestrogens and anti – androgens in the majority of bottled waters analyzed. In addition, the antagonistic activity is very powerful. Bottled water equivalent to 3.75 ml has restricted receptors of androgens and estrogens by up to 60-90% in a receptive manner. From a more general point of view, it has been discovered that bottled water from six different countries contains estrogenic chemicals [12], [13], [14], [15], [17] , anti-estrogens and anti-androgens. (this study), as well as androgenic, progestational and glucocorticoid chemicals [16] . This demonstrates that water is contaminated by various endocrine disruptors. (Source)

3. Bottled water could potentially be of lower quality than tap water

Not long ago the city of Cleveland did a test on the Fiji water mark and discovered that the water actually contained traces of arsenic, while the city’s water did not.

How is it possible?

“Bottled water manufacturers are not required to disclose as much information as municipal water utilities due to deficiencies in the federal supervisory authority, according to reports issued by government auditors.

The Food and Drug Administration oversees bottled water, and the US EPA is in charge of tap water. The FDA does not have the regulatory power of the EPA, said John Stephenson of the Government Accountability Office to a committee of the House. – Sarah Goodman of the New York Times

The list is long, and it’s pretty ridiculous when you think there are nearly a billion people on this planet who do not have access to clean water. Children are dying every minute of water-borne diseases, and we have spent billions of dollars trying to vaccinate them, but we are not doing the same to ensure safe drinking water for communities around the world.

Our greed seems to be the source of this problem … what do you think?

Source The bottled water denounced: Sources: … and

Update: following this article we have received a request for correction from the Chambre Syndicale des Eaux Minérales:

For the attention of Sain’s editor-in-chief


We will contact you after the article “The bottled water denounced & a list of brands that experts recommend to avoid”, published in October 2016 on your site: https: // MED /

This article contains erroneous and defamatory data against our profession; we want to clarify and rectify several points concerning bottled water in France

About fluoride

You are referring to fluoride in your article “Recent studies have shown that this chemical can do more harm than good, such as causing fluorosis – permanent tooth deformation. “Fluoride can also have a negative impact on their cognitive development.”

You then present a list of bottled waters that contain fluoride.

Know that fluorine is a natural mineral, its limit has been evaluated by EFSA1 and WHO2.

The regulation on mineral waters provides for a maximum fluorine content of 5mg / liter. If the fluorine concentration is higher than 1.5 mg / liter, a specific labeling statement is provided “Not suitable for infants and children under 7 years of age for regular consumption”.

The quality of bottled water

Reference is then made to an article in the Arab Tribune which states that “many brands actually use tap water and may contain fluoride”.

This is totally wrong. This article does not concern France: the Public Health Code defines the specificities of natural mineral water: it can only be of subterranean origin and be protected from any risk of pollution. Microbiologically sound from the beginning, it is protected from all human pollution and undergoes no disinfection treatment. It is characterized by its original purity and by the stability of its mineral composition: it is the only water to be able to benefit from properties favorable to the health recognized by the Academy of Medicine. Natural mineral water must be bottled at the source. It is subject to very strict regular controls from capture to bottling in order to ensure optimum consumer quality.

Bottled waters that contain fluoride (mg / l).

The contents indicated for each brand in your table are incorrect. For example :

  • VICHY CELESTINS 6.1> actually: 0.5
  • BADOIT 1.8> in reality: 1.2
  • ROZANA 0.7> actually: 0
  • CONTREX 0.3> actually: 0

The ecological impact of water bottles

“The manufacturing, transport and reprocessing of the 140,000 tonnes of plastic bottles that end up in waste each year in France have an impact on the environment”

  • The PET bottle is 100% recyclable. After being collected and sorted, it can be reused in many areas: making new bottles, clothes, pillows, teddy bears … Today, 60% of PET bottles are recycled. In order to increase the rate of collection and recycling, manufacturers are conducting consumer awareness campaigns with the sorting gesture with the posting of clear messages on the labels of their bottles. Latest action: an awareness campaign was conducted in June 2016 “Well sorted, this bottle is full of future” 3.In order to reduce the carbon footprint of the bottle, the natural mineral water industry has developed new bottles that, according to the brands, include a part of recycled plastic in the packaging or a percentage of PET of plant origin (molasses of sugar cane), process of manufacture more saving in oil. Know that the industrialists are also engaged concretely in collection actions in supermarkets and shopping centers, in companies, in local communities, during events … The PET is thus collected, sorted, then transformed into RPET so that the bottles have a second life. In addition, the natural mineral water industry has for several years been developing recourse to alternative modes of transport such as rail, piggyback and river transport in order to reduce the share of road transport. Currently, natural mineral water is transported by these alternative modes of transport up to 55%. Efforts have also been made on road transport with the use of increasingly energy-efficient trucks, which carry an ever-increasing number of bottles with a very low empty return rate.

“Tap water is 200 to 300 times cheaper than bottled water.”

Natural mineral water and tap water are different products: natural mineral water meets a specific regulation in the Public Health Code. The respect of these specificities which are the purity, the naturalness, the quality and the constant composition have a cost for the minerals. Significant investments are being made to preserve the natural sites from which the sources come. It is at the level of the impluvium, water infiltration zone, that the ore producers conduct source protection policies in collaboration with local stakeholders to prevent any risk of contamination of natural mineral water. The surface of an impluvium can cover several thousand hectares.

All these investments are taken into account in the price of natural mineral waters. Different products, by their nature, can not have the same price.

“Actually, it takes a lot of oil to make plastic bottles.”

As explained above, in order to reduce the carbon footprint of the bottle, the natural mineral water industry has developed new bottles which, according to the brands, include some recycled plastic in the packaging or a percentage of PET. of vegetable origin (cane molasses), manufacturing process more economical in oil.

Chemicals in the water

“Not long ago, German researchers discovered endocrine disruptors (EDs), which could harm the development and reproduction of 18 brands of bottled water. “

A study conducted by the independent laboratory of the CNRS-University of Bordeaux, specialized in research at the level of “ultra traces” (micro-particles) 4 has confirmed the very high quality bottled water in France. 13,000 analyzes were carried out on emerging pollutants, on 40 brands of bottled water in France. The research focused on 330 molecules: drugs, hormones, pesticides and other molecules related to human activities. This study has shown that:

There is no trace of medication, hormone, phthalate, or Bisphenol A in bottled water.

-100% of bottled water complies with the regulations on pesticides, at thresholds even 2 times lower than the regulatory limits.

Bottled water quality vs. tap water

“Bottled water could potentially be of lower quality than tap water”

As mentioned above, natural mineral waters and tap water are different products: natural mineral water meets specific regulations set out in the Public Health Code. It is characterized by its naturalness and its original purity. She does not undergo any disinfection treatment. Each source is monitored every two months by the Regional Health Agencies (ARS) and the ore producers conduct daily checks in parallel. The quality of natural mineral waters can not be questioned.

For more information, we invite you to visit the site. The Trade Union Chamber of Mineral Waters.

» Health » Bottled water denounced & a list of brands that experts recommend to avoid